InsightsPoint of View

Who Captures the Gains From AI Advertising

Why better advertising technology can increase competition—and change who keeps the profit

A rental operator completing a local equipment delivery at a commercial worksite.
By
Cam Myers
Content type
Point of View
Reading time
7 min read
Status
Author’s perspective
Topics
Demand Generation

In brief

  • Better conversion can increase what advertisers can afford to bid.
  • Cost to serve, repeat relationships, and operating capacity change the value of the same prospect.
  • The next customer’s contribution matters more than extending a favorable average return.

The argument

A business can get better at advertising and still find that growth costs more.

That possibility is missing from much of the discussion about AI marketing. The usual promise concerns efficiency: better targeting, cheaper creative production, less campaign work, more conversions. Those improvements can be real. Their value to an individual company depends on what happens after competitors gain access to similar capabilities.

Advertising is a competitive market. When a prospect becomes more valuable to reach, more businesses can afford to bid for the opportunity. Some of the improvement can therefore return to the platform through higher prices. Customers may receive another share through better offers. The advertiser keeps what remains after those responses and the cost of serving the additional business.

The question for an owner is how to build an advantage that survives that competition.

The decision underneath

Which advantages let this business retain the gains after competitors and platforms respond?

Better performance changes what advertisers can afford

Consider an illustrative midsized rental company in the northeastern United States. One in five qualified inquiries becomes a completed job, and each job contributes $300 before advertising and fixed overhead. A qualified inquiry is therefore worth an expected $60 at that conversion rate.

Suppose improvements in targeting and follow-up raise conversion to three in ten. The expected contribution per inquiry rises to $90. The company can now pay more for an inquiry while remaining profitable.

If its cost per inquiry rises from $45 to $65, the expected amount left after acquisition increases from $15 to $25. The advertiser benefits, even though acquisition becomes more expensive. The platform also benefits. The company has retained part of the gain.

These are illustrative figures, but the mechanism matters. A rising advertising price does not establish deteriorating economics. Equally, an improvement in conversion does not tell the owner how much additional profit will survive competition.

Meta's third-quarter 2026 filing offers a relevant market observation. Its average price per ad rose 14% year over year. Meta attributed increased advertising demand largely to improvements in targeting and measurement performance. That is the company's explanation of its results; the measure is not a forecast of local rental-company click costs.[1]

The broader economic possibility is clear. Making an advertising opportunity more productive can increase demand for that opportunity.

AI search introduces competing pressures

It is tempting to assume that customers moving some research into AI tools will make Google advertising cheaper. That skips several steps.

Research activity, advertising inventory, and valuable commercial visits are different quantities. A customer could conduct fewer exploratory searches, then arrive at Google with a short list and a purchase in mind. Those remaining visits may be especially valuable. If advertiser budgets remain committed to reaching them, bids could rise.

The opposite pressure is also plausible. Advertisers can move spending into new environments, reducing competition in an existing auction. New advertising inventory can expand the supply of opportunities. Better recommendations might shorten the buying journey or create purchases that otherwise would not happen.

There is no single direction for click prices that follows from AI adoption alone.

Nor does AI growth establish that Google search is shrinking. Alphabet reported growing commercial queries in its third-quarter 2026 results.[2] OpenAI, meanwhile, began testing ChatGPT ads in February 2026. It says paid placements remain separate from the answers ChatGPT produces.[3] An advertiser should distinguish buying a placement from earning an organic recommendation.

For an owner, the useful analysis follows a particular customer and market. Where does that customer research, compare, and commit? Which opportunities are available to buy? What are competitors willing to pay, and what makes the customer worth serving?

The advantage moves toward the business

If several rental operators use the same advertising tools, those tools do not make the operators economically identical.

One may deliver along an existing route. Another needs a separate trip. One may have spare equipment on the requested date. Another must decline the job or hire additional capacity. A third may convert more inquiries because its quoting and booking systems make it easier to complete the purchase.

The same prospect can therefore have a different value to each company.

That difference helps determine who can compete profitably for the customer. An operator with lower fulfillment costs can sometimes support a bid that would destroy a competitor's margin. An operator with dependable repeat business may justify a larger acquisition investment, provided that repeat value is supported by evidence and the company can finance the wait.

This is why campaign performance eventually reaches into the operation. More capable advertising software increases the importance of supplying it with commercially meaningful information. A lead from outside the practical service area should not acquire the same value as a nearby booking merely because both completed a form.

Automation can make a poorly chosen objective more efficient. It can also help a well-run business express advantages that broad lead counts conceal.

Cheaper production is easier to copy

AI can reduce the effort required to produce an advertisement, generate variations, or prepare a landing page. These are useful savings. They can also be available to most competitors.

A company should distinguish lower operating cost from lasting competitive advantage. The first can justify adoption without delivering the second. If every competitor can create competent advertisements quickly, the ability to produce another competent advertisement becomes a weaker explanation for superior results.

An offer customers prefer, credible evidence, a useful customer relationship, or a better cost to serve may be harder to reproduce. Those advantages still need effective advertising. Their economics do not originate entirely inside the advertising account.

There is also a timing issue. A business may enjoy meaningful gains before competitors catch up. Those gains can fund improvements elsewhere. Treating an early advantage as permanent, however, can support commitments that become expensive once the market adjusts.

The investment case should identify which benefits come from temporary access to a tool and which come from changes the company can continue to control.

Evaluate the next customer rather than the average report

An average return can conceal the point at which growth stops paying.

The first advertising dollars may reach nearby customers, established buyers, or people already close to a purchase. Additional spending may reach less suitable customers or require more expensive delivery. A healthy average does not establish that the next increase in budget will be equally productive.

Capacity changes the calculation too. An additional booking is attractive when equipment and delivery time are available. The same booking may displace a better job during a full week. Historical customer value cannot be applied without considering that opportunity cost.

I want advertising analysis to reach the contribution from additional business after acquisition and delivery costs. For auctions, that means the auction company's actual commissions and fees, rather than treating hammer value as its revenue. For rentals, it means the costs and commitments required to fulfill the booking. Where the evidence is uncertain, a bounded test is more useful than extending a favorable average indefinitely.

The measures should also explain whether better results come from attracting different customers, converting more effectively, or serving work more profitably. Each explanation points to a different investment.

An owner does not need a forecast of the entire advertising market before acting. The business needs to know why it can earn an acceptable return at the prices it faces, and what would cause that reasoning to stop holding.

AI may expand the amount of profitable demand a company can reach. It may also intensify competition for that demand. The businesses best placed to retain the gains will have a specific answer to why a customer is worth more to them, why the customer chooses them, and how they can deliver the work without giving the improvement back.

Sources and context

Business scenarios and figures are illustrative. Platform developments were checked on 10 November 2026. The competitive mechanisms discussed are the author's analysis.

  1. Meta, Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 September 2026. Average advertising prices and management's explanation of advertising demand.
  2. Alphabet, Third Quarter 2026 Results, 28 October 2026. Reported search growth does not establish the performance of a particular advertiser or market.
  3. OpenAI, Ads in ChatGPT. Advertising availability and the separation of paid placements from ChatGPT answers.

For the leadership team

In practice

  • Separate temporary access to a better tool from an advantage the business can maintain.
  • Connect acquisition decisions with contribution, service geography, and available capacity.
  • Test the next spending increase rather than assuming the average return will continue.

Questions worth asking

  1. Why is this customer worth more to us than to another supplier?
  2. Which improvement would remain valuable if every competitor adopted the same advertising tools?

Weighing this decision now? Tell us what you are considering and we will say plainly whether we can help.

Discuss your business